December 8, 2005

Katrina and the Racism Rehash

Marvin Olasky has a great piece in Townhall.com, Racist News Media, wherein he takes a long look at the things which were being said - and by whom - immediately after the levees broke. Recall that immediately after Katrina departed, everyone had thought that the city had dodged a bullet.

Writes Olasky,

In a congressional hearing Tuesday, liberals said that racism caused delays in Hurricane Katrina relief and rescue. They’re right, but they misidentified the culprit.

As I’ve reviewed records of the week of Aug., 28, an ugly picture has emerged: Some politicians and journalists painted a portrait of impoverished, overwhelmingly African-American masses of flood victims resorting to utter depravity, randomly attacking each other as well as the police and rescue workers trying to protect and save them. For example, Mayor Ray Nagin said many of his constituents were in an “almost animalistic state.”

Four days after the storm hit, black political organizer Randall Robinson said the “thousands of blacks in New Orleans … have begun eating corpses to survive.” Even for those who see cannibalism as benign, a feast after only four days is premature. CNN became hysterical about “groups of young men roaming the city, shooting at people, attempting to rape women.” Author Michael Lewis reduced the television message to a sentence: “Crazy black people with automatic weapons are out hunting white people, and there’s no bag limit.”

None of these rumors was true, as The New York Times belatedly reported a month after the winds died down: It called them “figments of frightened imaginations.” New Orleans Times-Picayune editor Jim Maoss also noted after the fact that if media had been characterizing the attitudes of “sweaty, hungry, desperate white people, middle-class white people, it’s hard to believe that these kinds of myths would have sprung up quite as readily.”

You’ll want to read the whole thing. I confess I turned off the television, so I didn’t get to hear Wolf Blitzer repeating that Katrina victims were “so poor, and so black…” Had I heard him, I would have sent this to him.

We saw earlier this week that those who speak most loudly about the evils of racism - and it is evil - are sometimes surprisingly slow to do more than speak loudly. Having the opportunity this week to peruse this book last weekend,

I learned that Michael Moore and Al Franken, who also sport very big mouths on the subject of how awful and racist Americans are, particular if they are those terrible conservative types, seem also to talk the talk while walking an entirely different walk.

Is racism a problem in America? Sure. It’s a problem everywhere. People always fear what they do not know or understand and stereotypes abound. But maybe it’s time for the press to acknowledge the tremendous strides that have been made since the GOP sponsored the Civil Rights Act back in the 1960’s. I’m not saying anyone has gloss over the problems that remain, but how about some stories about how many battles have been won? Or, you know…how about simply NOT reporting stories that are demonstrably untrue, simply because they are sensational or because they fan the flames and get the blood going?

Maybe this is why I came away from the Katrina story with a new respect for Lester Holt. He alone seemed sane and rational among the chattering newspeople. I hadn’t thought about it at the time, but perhaps he simply wasn’t interested in perpetuating stories and myths about African Americans which made them appear unable to function without government assistance, lacking heart, or spirit or initiative. Hello? Anyone recall Jabbor Gibson? He showed plenty of heart, spirit and initiative when he took one of the buses Mayor Nagin couldn’t be bothered deploying and rescued 100 people.

When the retrospects of 2005 are playing, later in the month, the story of Katrina will be told again. Will the press tell it straight, even unto admitting just how shoddily they had done their jobs? Or will we get the racism rehash?

Gateway Pundit has more, some of which suggests that the press will go for the Racism Rehash.

UPDATE/CORRECTION:
This post orignially cited the title of Olfasky’s piece as “Flooded by a Shallow News Media,” which was incorrect. That brilliant headline came courtesy of a heads-up email from Fornow. And it’s a much better headline than the other, so good, that I didn’t even notice it was not the headline that was published. All apologies to ForNow.


The Anchoress pinged back with The truth about the NOLA floods and Katrina
The Anchoress pinged back with Police Chief Admits Katrina crime “exaggerated…”
Ed Driscoll.com tracked back with It May Be A First Draft, But It's Written In Stone

by TheAnchoress @ 1:23 pm. Filed under America, Bush Good, Katrina/Rita
Trackback URL for this post:
http://theanchoressonline.com/2005/12/08/racism-and-katrina-and-moore/trackback/

6 Responses to “Katrina and the Racism Rehash”

  1. ForNow Says:

    Olasky’s article is entitled “Racist News Media.” The other title (”Flooded by a shallow news media”) was the subject line of the email from a long-time fan and occasional VRWC accomplice of yours, who uses the tag “ForNow,” bringing the article to your attention.

  2. Ed Driscoll.com Says:

    It May Be A First Draft, But It’s Written In Stone

    The Anchoress links to a powerful essay by Marvin Olasky on the racism displayed by the MSM in their coverage of Hurricane Katrina and writes:When the retrospects of 2005 are playing, later in the month, the story of Katrina will…

  3. TheAnchoress Says:

    Ack, ForNOw is completely correct! I hadn’t even realized it! I just saw his header and thought that was the headline (it was a good one!) Sorry, For Now…I will Correct!

  4. ForNow Says:

    You owe me no apologies, A! I’m just sorry that I occasioned a mixup.

    Anyway the Katrina misreporting deserves serious study. There was liberal racism and there were also honest and well-meaning mistakes that any of us could make. Suppose you’re on the street and on the phone to a friend working at a newspaper. People on the street tell you in all earnestness and seriousness that people are getting shot in the next neighborhood. Do you play it down or tell it urgently to your friend at the newspaper? A neighbor of mine told me that a woman told him on the phone that her mother, a nurse in or near New Orleans, told her that people were firing at helicopters trying to land on the hospital roof in order to evacuate babies. I posted about it in various places. I now wonder whether it was true.

  5. The Anchoress » Police Chief Admits Katrina crime “exaggerated…” Says:

    [...] Related:Both Parties Entwined in Mediocrity Katrina Facts and Fiction NOLA deaths greatly exaggerated Blanco’s refusal at the core of the chaos No, the MSM will not, Captain, Sorry “Reality Based” madness 100 Hours after Stormfall Katrina and the Racism Rehash NOLA turned down help? [...]

  6. The Anchoress » The truth about the NOLA floods and Katrina Says:

    [...] A year ago: Both Parties Entwined in Mediocrity Katrina Facts and Fiction NOLA deaths greatly exaggerated Blanco’s refusal at the core of the chaos No, the MSM will not, Captain, Sorry “Reality Based” madness 100 Hours after Stormfall Katrina and the Racism Rehash NOLA turned down help? Katrina/Rita. [...]

Bad Behavior has blocked 25412 access attempts in the last 7 days.