|
February 7, 2006Cartoon News you can use - UPDATEDVaughn Ververs at CBS’ Public Eye has a well-written and strong piece up examining the mainstream media’s reluctance to print the “offensive” cartoons even though a story this huge sort of demands it: “…All of which brings us to the role of Western media, specifically U.S. media, in this face-off. Often lost in discussing this story is the fact that the cartoons were originally printed in a Danish newspaper some five months ago (conspiracy theories are currently raging as to why they’ve suddenly become a flashpoint but that’s for another time). Since the initial protests last week, many news outlets in Europe have re-published or aired the drawings in support of freedom of speech, which has resulted in more outrage among Muslims. So far, almost every U.S. news outlet has refrained from following suit. [...] It’s a responsible position to withhold images that offend common sensibilities and exist only to degrade or inspire action against a particular group. But when those images become the basis for a major global story, it becomes less defensible. Add in the availability of access to the drawings on the Internet and the refusal on the part of major media outlets to recreate the images starts looking like a head-in-the-sand exercise. Perhaps part of the reason the U.S. media is reluctant to show them is because most of us would scratch our heads in disbelief over how they could possibly spark such violence. Just about any group or belief you can imagine – Catholics, Evangelicals, Jews, Hispanics, Blacks, Men, Women and even Canadians – are treated much worse. And so ingrained is the freedom of expression, that it’s generally tolerated, even celebrated at times. When Christians are subjected to images like “Piss Christ,” why, we would ask, should Muslims be exempt? Why should the American press have a separate standard of religious sensitivity? Is the American press actually more scared of being targeted by protests or violence than they admit? This is your must-read of the day. It is lucid, well thought-out and it when you’re feeling fed-up with the press, it gives hope. Pieces like this are why Public Eye is in my blogroll, and why I’m usually so happy to link to them. It may be the last legitimate gem in the former “Tiffany” network’s rather tarnished crown. Iraq the Model breaks silence: I give up! I have to comment on the general situation… You know that those cartoons were published for the 1st time months ago and we here in the Middle East have tonnes of jokes about Allah, the prophets and the angels that are way more offensive, funny and obscene than those poorly-made cartoons, yet no one ever got shot for telling one of those jokes or at least we had never seen rallies and protests against those infidel joke-tellers. Omar thinks if anyone is expecting apologies to soothe things over, they are sadly deluded. And since Gateway Pundit is now reporting that EGYPT published these cartoons 5 months ago, I suspect he is correct. This whole “event” has been nothing but a champertous contrivance. See Freedom for Egyptians. Dr. Sanity writes on a sense of humor and what it requires, and what it says about you, if you cannot laugh at yourself. A very good read: The healthiest kind of humor is the kind that allows an outlet for pain and at the same time gives pleasure. It deflates without destroying; and exposes our pretensions before they are taken too seriously. The painful feelings that often underlie humor if expressed another way would be destructive or eat away at the soul. In this way, humor can be as redemptive as the most creative artistic endeavor. Jonah Goldberg reports on unrest in the Jewish street. Victoria gets thoughtful rather than angry The freedom of speech does not mean the freedom to say what you want without a reaction. It just guarantees your right to reasonable expressions of thought. Spengler wonders Why can’t Muslims Take a Joke? (Fedora Tip to Roger Simon). That’s news to me, and troubling. Very troubling, indeed. Thomas Sowell suggests we are drifting toward a point of no return. Barcepundit remembers when Sinead O’ Connor went too far and doesn’t recall boycotts of Guinness or riots in the street. Don’t forget about the Twelfth Imam. Michelle Malkin is being called a bigot, etc, again because she is unapologetic and direct. She links to (and excerpts) a particularly adolescent article which would like to, apparently, blame the blogs for unrest and deaths, and which is oooooohhhhh soooooo klever when it uses the phrase “Kartoon Karnage Kapers,” because, you know…Michelle is a conservative, so she must be the equivalent of the KKK. And liberals accuse conservatives of “writing in code!” What a punk. Writes Michelle: Michelle is a petite woman with enormous shoulders and boundless courage. She and I differ now and again in method or message, but I have enormous respect for her energy, her committment, her spine-of-steel, her forthrightness and her generosity. This is crap up with which she should not have to put. But then again…she’s not exactly putting up with it, she’s giving it right back, in spades! Check back - I’ll likely be adding more links before the end of the evening! http://theanchoressonline.com/2006/02/07/cartoon-news-you-can-use/trackback/ 7 Responses to “Cartoon News you can use - UPDATED” |
Bad Behavior has blocked 25599 access attempts in the last 7 days.
February 7th, 2006 at 10:39 pm
Here’s the Newsweek story –
Challenging the Qur’an
Newsweek July 28, 2003
By Stefan Theil
found here (Body of text deleted due to copyright concerns - admin)
February 7th, 2006 at 10:41 pm
Bender where did you find that?
February 7th, 2006 at 11:10 pm
In addition to the secret place where I got it, others can get it at –
http://www.mgr.org/ChallengingTheQuran.html
February 7th, 2006 at 11:34 pm
Bender, excellent post.
Might I add that what is never repeated are the Quranic admonitions that prior to Mohammed’s return, the Jews must return to the Promised Land.
Surprise, surprise.
Further, there are variants of the text itself.
Oh, the gates you have opened!
Well done, Bender.
February 7th, 2006 at 11:56 pm
The original Qur’an, Luxenberg contends, was in fact a Christian liturgical document.
Well, I seriously doubt that, at least as far as the English translation of the Arabic is concerned, which, inter alia, insists that Mary was the sister of Moses, denies that Jesus was actually crucified, and repeatedly shows that the concepts of Jesus as the Son of God and the Trinity are completely beyond Allah’s comprehension and understanding.
February 8th, 2006 at 2:28 am
Anchoress, as ever, thanks for linking to what you call, my thoughtful post.
Yes, I tried to point out the differences in our two monotheistic religions, without getting angry, or bitter at the current goings-on.
But in my post’s comments section, a reader demands the Muslim world grow up.
I replied:
Well, if we say it like that, they will (rightly) get very defensive.
Instead, we (we who? Not me, probably not you, but you understand what I mean) have to appeal to the most educated elements of their society — many of whom are religious, but urbane.
The problem is how do we offer them the high ideals of the Enlightenment as rewards, when the other side offers them the cold steel of a blade against the neck, as a punishment?
This is why we in the West fight so much to preserve our freedoms, even when we don’t like where those freedoms take us, like the Kanye West pic above.
It is a hard thing, to be on the side of those who would mock your religion, and trample on all you believe in, but if the price of freedom from physical punishment for the expression of our beliefs, and opinions is that, then I for one, am willing to pay it.
Cheers,
Victoria
February 8th, 2006 at 6:33 pm
[...] - ANCHORESS: Cartoon News you can use - UPDATED … (theanchoressonline) [...]