March 23, 2007

The Immorality of Global Warming Moralizing

I like this essay by Tim Thorstenson at American Thinker:

As a scientist, I find the current strategy of the global warming crusade to be fascinating. Particularly because I am a scientist, I also find it insulting.
[...]
For many years, global warming seemed to be a fact-focused debate. But a persistent problem for the advocates has been dissenting scientific opinion. Some very reputable scientists hold that global warming may be attributed to natural phenomena like the intensity of solar radiation.

Others have valid questions about how much warming will actually occur and how severe the resulting effects will really be. Still others suggest that, if the problem is indeed real and serious, then serious responses are indicated. These folks propose an honest examination of real solutions (like a renewed emphasis on nuclear power) instead of the childish games of useless treaties, carbon credits, windmills and fluorescent light bulbs that seem to enamor so many of the advocates.

It is one thing to write these dissenting opinions off as factually false, but this is apparently no longer regarded as adequate by the global warming advocates. The dissent keeps popping up, it backed by some very reputable people wielding very credible facts, and the availability of alternate information outlets has made it impossible to smother the doubters and dissenters.

Now enter the moral angle. If global warming is now a moral matter, it would seem to suggest an associated implication that these inconvenient viewpoints are immoral. Apparently it is now the duty of “good” people to reject these opinions on this “moral” basis and without regard to whether they are factually true or false.

The most bizarre aspect of this strategy is that it is exactly what the liberals have always (unfairly) accused us conservatives of doing. Here, morality is not being used as a lens through which to view the facts, but rather as a hammer that can smash the inconvenient ones.

Read, as they say, the whole thing.


The High Church of H.O.G.W.A.S.H. « Obi’s Sister pinged back with The High Church of H.O.G.W.A.S.H. « Obi’s Sister
The Anchoress pinged back with The Accidental Acronym
Pirate's Cove tracked back with Sorta Blogless Sunday Pinup
Maggie's Farm tracked back with A few Saturday Links
The Immorality of Global Warming Moralizing pinged back with The Immorality of Global Warming Moralizing

by TheAnchoress @ 1:20 pm. Filed under Hoo-Hah & BS
Trackback URL for this post:
http://theanchoressonline.com/2007/03/23/the-immorality-of-global-warming-moralizing/trackback/

9 Responses to “The Immorality of Global Warming Moralizing”

  1. GJMiller Says:

    Don’t you find that when someone hasn’t a convincing or well-reasoned argument, they want to immediately shut down any who disagree with them? This is the childlike behavior and is the equivalent of putting your hands over your ears and chanting loudly “nya, nya, nya”!

  2. The Immorality of Global Warming Moralizing Says:

    [...] post by Carbon Credits News by Carbon Credit News Posted by [...]

  3. smmtheory Says:

    And the worst of it is, legislatures are considering enacting laws imposing fines on companies (like power companies} that do not cut their carbon “footprint” down enough. As if that is going to help. Guess who is going to foot that bill…

  4. Maggie's Farm Says:

    A few Saturday Links

    Bush’s speech yesterday on video, if you missed it. Hot AirMassachusetts shows us how to do it right. WizbangDaddy government and Mommy government. One Cosmos. Transference is strong stuff, isn’t it?Kristol and Kagan. Wrong on Timetables. Weekly Stan…

  5. Pirate's Cove Says:

    Sorta Blogless Sunday Pinup

    And a happy Sunday to all! This pinup is obviously by Gil Elvgren, with a little help. It's almost that time for sun and fun at the beach, don't ya think?
    What's happening out there?

    Blogs for Bush has an incredible video about "How …

  6. WDG Says:

    I like Mr. Thorstenson’s labeling Mr. Gore as the “High Priest of Global Warning.” Perhaps, Anchoress, you’d be doing blog surfers a favor if, in the future, you refer to the former V-P’s rantings with just such a link reference:

    Highpriest
    Of
    Global
    Warming
    As
    Stated
    Here

    (just read down vertically.)

  7. The Anchoress » The Accidental Acronym Says:

    [...] Accidental Acronym The Immorality of Global Warming Moralizing Couple of quick thoughts on a busy day Yesterday’s Prayers well-answered! Yeehaw, [...]

  8. benning Says:

    The urge to criminalize the opinions of those who disagree with the Global Warming Theories has begun. And it is every bit as dangerous as anything the Nazis, Communists, and Muslims have attempted, and continue to attempt.

  9. The High Church of H.O.G.W.A.S.H. « Obi’s Sister Says:

    [...] spring, you know that 48 hour period in the South between Winter and Summer, The Anchoress posted a quickie about an excellent American Thinker essay on Global Warming. One of her commentors made a funny [...]

Bad Behavior has blocked 25656 access attempts in the last 7 days.